Brown Choices for the Exterior

Here is the brown pallette we're considering from the Sherwin Williams Historical Collection for the exterior.  We go back and forth between the greens and the browns.  We think both look good on the lake.  It's just a matter of picking one.  Once we've narrowed the field I'll probably buy a sample of each and paint on some Hardieplank scraps.

SW 2835 Craftsman Brown from Sherwin-Williams for the body

SW 2833 Roycroft Vellum from Sherwin-Williams for trim

 SW 2836 Quartersawn Oak from Sherwin-Williams for accent (garage doors)

Any thoughts and comments are appreciated.  I loved reading everybody's suggestions reguarding the greens.